Apr 15, 2025

Categories of Invalidity in Norwegian Contract Law: Total, Partial, Absolute, Relative, Strong, and Weak

Categories of Invalidity in Norwegian Contract Law: Total, Partial, Absolute, Relative, Strong, and Weak
Categories of Invalidity in Norwegian Contract Law: Total, Partial, Absolute, Relative, Strong, and Weak
Categories of Invalidity in Norwegian Contract Law: Total, Partial, Absolute, Relative, Strong, and Weak

Invalidity in contract law is not a single entity, but appears in several different forms with various legal effects. This article explores the central categories of invalidity in Norwegian law: full and partial invalidity, absolute and relative grounds for invalidity, as well as strong and weak grounds for invalidity. Understanding these distinctions is crucial for assessing a contract's validity and the legal remedies available.

Total and Partial Invalidity

Main Rule: Total Invalidity

The main rule in Norwegian contract law is that a contract affected by a ground for invalidity will be entirely invalid. Consequently, courts typically only have the option between full validity or full invalidity of the contract.

Reservations and Exceptions

There are several important reservations from this main rule:

1. Divisible Performances

When a single contract contains multiple performances that are divisible in the sense that each individual performance can be independently disposed of, there may be grounds for partial invalidity.

This is particularly relevant if the disposition consists of several independent performances where the consideration is determined for each performance. An example is a contract for the delivery of several ships in the same contract, where invalidity affects only the ships not yet delivered.

2. Localized Invalidity Defects

Partial invalidity can also arise where the factor causing the invalidity only "clings" to a part of the contract. This could be the case, for example, where a promissory note for 100,000 kroner is partly based on a remainder of a purchase price and partly on a loan given under illegal terms.

3. The Contracts Act § 36

In cases of invalidity under the Contracts Act § 36, there is openness for a more nuanced approach to legal effects. Here, courts may choose to modify the contract content instead of declaring it completely invalid.

4. The Price Regulation Act

Regarding invalidity under the Price Regulation Act § 2, the financial legal effects follow from the same Act’s § 6, which allows for a more nuanced assessment of the legal effects.

5. Content Defects

In cases of invalidity due to content defects, typically where the contract violates law or decency (NL 5-1-2), it is often only the parts of the contract that are unlawful that will be nullified. However, the nullification of a clause that is of significant importance to one party can trigger "full" invalidity for the entire contract.

When a clause is nullified, principles from the Contracts Act § 36 or presumption may be used to supplement the contract, ensuring that lawful rights under the contract are preserved. Alternatively, this could result from interpreting the contract.

Absolute and Relative Grounds for Invalidity

Starting Point: No Waiver of Invalidity in Advance

A party cannot, before or in connection with entering a contract, commit to the contract not being set aside as invalid. This follows from the mandatory nature of the invalidity rules.

Relative Grounds for Invalidity

However, in many cases, the parties may after entering the contract approve (ratify) the promise, thereby repairing the invalidity. Grounds for invalidity that can be repaired by subsequent approval are called relative grounds for invalidity.

Absolute Grounds for Invalidity

Absolute grounds for invalidity, on the other hand, cannot be repaired subsequently. This covers:

  • Promises that violate law or decency (NL 5-1-2)

  • Instances where the approval is affected by the same ground for invalidity as the "main promise"

An example of the latter is that a person with a mental disorder cannot approve a disposition motivated by the mental disorder through another disposition also motivated by the same disorder.

Main Rule: Relative Invalidity

The main rule in Norwegian law is that grounds for invalidity are relative, with the mentioned exceptions.

Strong and Weak Grounds for Invalidity

The distinction between weak and strong invalidity is fundamental in the doctrine of invalidity.

Strong Grounds for Invalidity

A strong ground for invalidity can be asserted even against a promisee in good faith, i.e., who did not exhibit negligence at the time of the promise.

Examples of strong grounds for invalidity:

  • Gross coercion

  • Incompetence

  • Mental disorder

  • Contractual relationships contrary to NL 5-1-2

  • Forgery, falsification, and misrepresentation

Weak Grounds for Invalidity

A weak ground for invalidity, on the other hand, can only be invoked against a promisee in bad faith or negligent.

Examples of weak grounds for invalidity:

  • Fraud

  • Minor coercion

  • Misapprehension, including cases covered by the Contracts Act § 33

The timing for assessing good faith is regulated by the Contracts Act § 39.

Significance of the Distinction

The distinction between weak and strong invalidity primarily matters for the invalidity rules where the legislator has attempted to address the conflict between one party's will and the other's expectation ("will and declaration"), typically regarding defects upon formation according to the Contracts Act §§ 28-33.

For content defects, primarily covered by the Contracts Act § 36, the distinction is mainly irrelevant. This is because the condition causing invalidity will generally be equally "visible" to both contracting parties.

Nevertheless, certain reservations must be made concerning the Contracts Act § 36, where the promisee's bad faith can, in some cases, be relevant for the assessment.

Summary

The categories of invalidity in Norwegian contract law provide a nuanced picture of when and how contracts can be deemed invalid:

  1. Full/Partial Invalidity: Determines whether the entire contract or just parts of it are invalid

  2. Absolute/Relative Invalidity: Determines whether invalidity can be repaired by subsequent approval

  3. Strong/Weak Invalidity: Determines whether the counterparty's good faith protects against invalidity

These distinctions are crucial for assessing the legal effects of invalid contracts and the possibilities for salvaging parts of the contract or repairing the invalidity. Knowledge of these categories is therefore essential when legally advising on agreements that may be subject to grounds for invalidity.

Sterk Law Firm

Security through watertight agreements

Security through watertight agreements

Security through watertight agreements

Contracts form the framework for most binding relationships, whether in business or private life. A good contract creates predictability, allocates risk, and prevents conflicts. Inadequate contract regulation can, at worst, lead to prolonged disputes or significant financial losses. At Sterk Law Firm, you get a personal and pragmatic lawyer who understands your needs. We take the time to understand your business and industry so that we can tailor the terms to your purpose. At the same time, we pay attention to details and the "fine print" that can have major consequences. You can be assured that your rights and obligations are clearly and unambiguously set out. We have particular expertise in contracts related to construction, IT, commerce, real estate, and corporate matters. However, we also assist with more standalone agreements such as letters of intent, confidentiality agreements, leases, service agreements, and craftsmanship services. When necessary, we draw on the specialized expertise of our external partners. Most assignments begin with an assessment of the contract's purpose and the needs of the parties. We then review any drafts or offers from the counterparty and provide an evaluation of which terms should be included, amended, or removed. If desired, we can also draft the entire contract from scratch. Along the way, we maintain close communication with you as a client, ensuring you always have control over the process. We offer both ongoing advice and assistance with individual contracts. Our goal is to create long-term client relationships, and many choose us as their regular contract partner. We offer competitive prices and can provide advantageous framework agreements for businesses. Contact us today to find out what we can do for your business or contractual situation!

Contracts form the framework for most binding relationships, whether in business or private life. A good contract creates predictability, allocates risk, and prevents conflicts. Inadequate contract regulation can, at worst, lead to prolonged disputes or significant financial losses. At Sterk Law Firm, you get a personal and pragmatic lawyer who understands your needs. We take the time to understand your business and industry so that we can tailor the terms to your purpose. At the same time, we pay attention to details and the "fine print" that can have major consequences. You can be assured that your rights and obligations are clearly and unambiguously set out. We have particular expertise in contracts related to construction, IT, commerce, real estate, and corporate matters. However, we also assist with more standalone agreements such as letters of intent, confidentiality agreements, leases, service agreements, and craftsmanship services. When necessary, we draw on the specialized expertise of our external partners. Most assignments begin with an assessment of the contract's purpose and the needs of the parties. We then review any drafts or offers from the counterparty and provide an evaluation of which terms should be included, amended, or removed. If desired, we can also draft the entire contract from scratch. Along the way, we maintain close communication with you as a client, ensuring you always have control over the process. We offer both ongoing advice and assistance with individual contracts. Our goal is to create long-term client relationships, and many choose us as their regular contract partner. We offer competitive prices and can provide advantageous framework agreements for businesses. Contact us today to find out what we can do for your business or contractual situation!

Contracts form the framework for most binding relationships, whether in business or private life. A good contract creates predictability, allocates risk, and prevents conflicts. Inadequate contract regulation can, at worst, lead to prolonged disputes or significant financial losses. At Sterk Law Firm, you get a personal and pragmatic lawyer who understands your needs. We take the time to understand your business and industry so that we can tailor the terms to your purpose. At the same time, we pay attention to details and the "fine print" that can have major consequences. You can be assured that your rights and obligations are clearly and unambiguously set out. We have particular expertise in contracts related to construction, IT, commerce, real estate, and corporate matters. However, we also assist with more standalone agreements such as letters of intent, confidentiality agreements, leases, service agreements, and craftsmanship services. When necessary, we draw on the specialized expertise of our external partners. Most assignments begin with an assessment of the contract's purpose and the needs of the parties. We then review any drafts or offers from the counterparty and provide an evaluation of which terms should be included, amended, or removed. If desired, we can also draft the entire contract from scratch. Along the way, we maintain close communication with you as a client, ensuring you always have control over the process. We offer both ongoing advice and assistance with individual contracts. Our goal is to create long-term client relationships, and many choose us as their regular contract partner. We offer competitive prices and can provide advantageous framework agreements for businesses. Contact us today to find out what we can do for your business or contractual situation!

Advokatfirmaet Sterk
Advokatfirmaet Sterk
Advokatfirmaet Sterk

We draft contracts that protect your interests

We draft contracts that protect your interests

We draft contracts that protect your interests

Explore

More articles

Interpretation Rules and Standard Contracts in Norwegian Contract Law

Contracts

Apr 15, 2025

Interpretation Rules and Standard Contracts in Norwegian Contract Law

Interpretation rules are unwritten principles that provide guidance when the interpretative factors do not indicate a specific outcome in contract interpretation. The rule of ambiguity, the most central interpretative rule in Norwegian law, implies that the contract is interpreted against the party who should have expressed themselves more clearly. The minimum rule suggests that the least burdensome alternative for the promisor is chosen. For standard contracts, special considerations apply, but recent case law shows that these are also interpreted according to general interpretative principles. Particularly for 'agreed documents,' decisive weight is given to the wording, while unilateral standard terms are more often interpreted restrictively in favor of the weaker party.

Interpretation Rules and Standard Contracts in Norwegian Contract Law

Contracts

Apr 15, 2025

Interpretation Rules and Standard Contracts in Norwegian Contract Law

Interpretation rules are unwritten principles that provide guidance when the interpretative factors do not indicate a specific outcome in contract interpretation. The rule of ambiguity, the most central interpretative rule in Norwegian law, implies that the contract is interpreted against the party who should have expressed themselves more clearly. The minimum rule suggests that the least burdensome alternative for the promisor is chosen. For standard contracts, special considerations apply, but recent case law shows that these are also interpreted according to general interpretative principles. Particularly for 'agreed documents,' decisive weight is given to the wording, while unilateral standard terms are more often interpreted restrictively in favor of the weaker party.

Interpretation Rules and Standard Contracts in Norwegian Contract Law

Contracts

Apr 15, 2025

Interpretation Rules and Standard Contracts in Norwegian Contract Law

Interpretation rules are unwritten principles that provide guidance when the interpretative factors do not indicate a specific outcome in contract interpretation. The rule of ambiguity, the most central interpretative rule in Norwegian law, implies that the contract is interpreted against the party who should have expressed themselves more clearly. The minimum rule suggests that the least burdensome alternative for the promisor is chosen. For standard contracts, special considerations apply, but recent case law shows that these are also interpreted according to general interpretative principles. Particularly for 'agreed documents,' decisive weight is given to the wording, while unilateral standard terms are more often interpreted restrictively in favor of the weaker party.

Contract Interpretation in Norwegian Law: Key Principles and Methods

Contracts

Apr 15, 2025

Contract Interpretation in Norwegian Law: Key Principles and Methods

Contract interpretation is a central aspect of contract law and concerns establishing the legal effects that an entered agreement has between the parties. In Norwegian law, the interpretation process primarily follows the objective interpretation principle but can be modified by the mutual understanding of the parties. In cases of unclear wording, the purpose of the agreement, the expectations of the parties, and genuine considerations are emphasized. Commercial agreements are interpreted particularly strictly according to their wording. In cases of persistent ambiguity, the agreement may be supplemented with solutions from background law. The good faith standard protects parties who had a legitimate expectation of how the agreement should be understood.

Contract Interpretation in Norwegian Law: Key Principles and Methods

Contracts

Apr 15, 2025

Contract Interpretation in Norwegian Law: Key Principles and Methods

Contract interpretation is a central aspect of contract law and concerns establishing the legal effects that an entered agreement has between the parties. In Norwegian law, the interpretation process primarily follows the objective interpretation principle but can be modified by the mutual understanding of the parties. In cases of unclear wording, the purpose of the agreement, the expectations of the parties, and genuine considerations are emphasized. Commercial agreements are interpreted particularly strictly according to their wording. In cases of persistent ambiguity, the agreement may be supplemented with solutions from background law. The good faith standard protects parties who had a legitimate expectation of how the agreement should be understood.

Contract Interpretation in Norwegian Law: Key Principles and Methods

Contracts

Apr 15, 2025

Contract Interpretation in Norwegian Law: Key Principles and Methods

Contract interpretation is a central aspect of contract law and concerns establishing the legal effects that an entered agreement has between the parties. In Norwegian law, the interpretation process primarily follows the objective interpretation principle but can be modified by the mutual understanding of the parties. In cases of unclear wording, the purpose of the agreement, the expectations of the parties, and genuine considerations are emphasized. Commercial agreements are interpreted particularly strictly according to their wording. In cases of persistent ambiguity, the agreement may be supplemented with solutions from background law. The good faith standard protects parties who had a legitimate expectation of how the agreement should be understood.

Approval of Invalid Dispositions: Ratification in Norwegian Contract Law

Contracts

Apr 15, 2025

Approval of Invalid Dispositions: Ratification in Norwegian Contract Law

Can an agreement that is initially invalid be subsequently ratified and thereby obtain legal effect? This article explains when an invalid disposition can be remedied through subsequent approval (ratification), what limitations apply to various grounds for invalidity, and how a bona fide co-contractor may oppose such ratification. A key aspect of contract law that balances the consideration of freedom of contract against the need to protect weaker parties.

Approval of Invalid Dispositions: Ratification in Norwegian Contract Law

Contracts

Apr 15, 2025

Approval of Invalid Dispositions: Ratification in Norwegian Contract Law

Can an agreement that is initially invalid be subsequently ratified and thereby obtain legal effect? This article explains when an invalid disposition can be remedied through subsequent approval (ratification), what limitations apply to various grounds for invalidity, and how a bona fide co-contractor may oppose such ratification. A key aspect of contract law that balances the consideration of freedom of contract against the need to protect weaker parties.

Approval of Invalid Dispositions: Ratification in Norwegian Contract Law

Contracts

Apr 15, 2025

Approval of Invalid Dispositions: Ratification in Norwegian Contract Law

Can an agreement that is initially invalid be subsequently ratified and thereby obtain legal effect? This article explains when an invalid disposition can be remedied through subsequent approval (ratification), what limitations apply to various grounds for invalidity, and how a bona fide co-contractor may oppose such ratification. A key aspect of contract law that balances the consideration of freedom of contract against the need to protect weaker parties.

Content Deficiencies in Agreements: Legal Overview and Consequences

Contracts

Apr 15, 2025

Content Deficiencies in Agreements: Legal Overview and Consequences

When is an agreement invalid due to its content? This article provides an overview of central rules regarding content defects, ranging from agreements about games and betting to the general leniency rule in the Contracts Act § 36. The article explains when courts may set aside or amend agreements with unreasonable content, and how consumers have special protection through the Contracts Act § 37. Key decisions from the Supreme Court illustrate how the rules operate in practice.

Content Deficiencies in Agreements: Legal Overview and Consequences

Contracts

Apr 15, 2025

Content Deficiencies in Agreements: Legal Overview and Consequences

When is an agreement invalid due to its content? This article provides an overview of central rules regarding content defects, ranging from agreements about games and betting to the general leniency rule in the Contracts Act § 36. The article explains when courts may set aside or amend agreements with unreasonable content, and how consumers have special protection through the Contracts Act § 37. Key decisions from the Supreme Court illustrate how the rules operate in practice.

Content Deficiencies in Agreements: Legal Overview and Consequences

Contracts

Apr 15, 2025

Content Deficiencies in Agreements: Legal Overview and Consequences

When is an agreement invalid due to its content? This article provides an overview of central rules regarding content defects, ranging from agreements about games and betting to the general leniency rule in the Contracts Act § 36. The article explains when courts may set aside or amend agreements with unreasonable content, and how consumers have special protection through the Contracts Act § 37. Key decisions from the Supreme Court illustrate how the rules operate in practice.

Contact us

Contact Sterk Law Firm for legal assistance and advice. Our dedicated team of experienced lawyers is ready to find tailored solutions for your specific challenges.

Portrait of a man in a suit with arms crossed, in front of a graphic background – expressing professionalism and confidence
Portrait of a man in a suit with arms crossed, in front of a graphic background – expressing professionalism and confidence

By submitting this form, you agree to our privacy policy and terms of service.